An analysis of the original purpose of the constitutional convention

The official papers of the Convention sat in the Department of State, untouched, until Yet in retrospect, the gathering reveals both the men and the issues they faced during the founding era. Through analysis of both the Philadelphia debates and the various ratification conventions, we realize the concerns and needs of a developing nation.

An analysis of the original purpose of the constitutional convention

Originally published as 2 Hastings Const. Reprinted in the Senate Reportpg. For educational use only. The printed edition remains canonical.

Related Posts

For citational use please obtain a back issue from William S. Guns and the Constitution As a result of a steadily rising crime rate in recent years, a sharp public debate over the merits of federal firearms regulation has developed. The number of robberies jumped fromin toinwhile murders committed by guns shot up from 5, to 10, in the same period, and the proportion of cases in which the murder weapon was a firearm rose from Kennedy, and the maiming of George Wallace.

Many people assert that these tragedies could have been prevented by keeping the murder weapons out of the hands that used them. Others vehemently dispute this claim. The free flow of firearms across state lines has undermined the traditional view of crime and gun control as local problems.

In New York City, long noted for strict regulation of all types of weapons, only 19 percent of the homicides of involved pistols, bythis proportion had jumped to 49 percent of 1, The great majority of the American people now support registration of both handguns and rifles.

An analysis of the original purpose of the constitutional convention

When the Gallup Poll asked the p. Even gun-owners endorsed registration by a margin of 55 percent to 39 percent with 6 percent undecided. American history has often seen social and political problems transformed into constitutional issues.

They therefore assert that "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms" is a collective right which protects only members of the organized militia, e. It is their belief that no one else can claim a personal right p.

Opponents maintain that having guns is a constitutionally protected individual right, similar to other guarantees of the Bill of Rights. Some hold this right to be absolute, while others would allow reasonable restrictions, perhaps even licensing and registration.

Still others would limit the protection of the Second Amendment to individuals capable of military service and to weapons useful for military purposes. The essential characteristic of the "individualist" interpretation, as opposed to the "collectivist" view, is that the Second Amendment precludes, to some extent at least, congressional interference in the private use of firearms for lawful purposes such as target shooting, hunting and self-defense.

It is one of the ironies of contemporary politics that the many of the most vocal supporters of "law and order" are persistent critics of federal firearms regulation.

Whereas strict constructionism is often the preferred doctrine in interpreting the constitutional rights of criminals, such a narrow view of the Second Amendment is unacceptable. Far from being narrowly construed, the Second Amendment is held out to be a bulwark of human freedom and dignity as well as a means of safeguarding the rights of the individual against encroachment by the federal government.

It thus becomes a weapon in the arsenal of argument against gun control, and each new proposal is said to infringe upon the rights of the people to keep and bear arms.In the context of United States constitutional interpretation, originalism is a way to interpret the Constitution's meaning as stable from the time of enactment, which can be changed only by the steps set out in Article Five.

The term originated in the s. Originalism is an umbrella term for interpretative methods that hold to the "fixation . The original purpose of the Constitutional Convention of was to what Get the answers you need, now!5/5(11). Original Intentions: On the Making and Ratification of the United States Constitution [M.

E. Bradford] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. This persuasively argued, decidedly partisan work aims to recover the original United States Constitution by describing its genesis.

the original purpose of the Constitutional Convention was to. discuss trade regulation The delegates to the Constitutional Convention shared a commitment to. liberty. Sophisticated statistical analysis of the voting behavior of the Framers of the Constitution suggests. The original purpose of the Constitutional Convention of was to A.

revise the Articles of Confederation. B. solve the slavery issue. C. elect the first president of the United States. D. develop the principle of states'' rights/5(31). The original purpose of the Constitutional Convention was to revise the Articles of Confederation. However, it really turned into a debate on how America should .

Standing Armies And Armed Citizens: An Historical Analysis of The Second Amendment